Skip to content


On the importance of a To-Do List, and 5 strategies to get TDL items completed

Having a To-Do List, and a schedule of activities, is KEY.

“What then shall I do this morning? How we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives. What we do with this hour, and that one, is what we are doing. A schedule defends from chaos and whim. It is a net for catching days. It is a scaffolding on which a worker can stand and labor with both hands at sections of time. A schedule is a mock-up of reason and order-willed, faked, and so brought into being; it is a peace and a haven set into the wreck of time; it is a lifeboat on which you find yourself, decades later, still living. Each day is the same, so you remember the series afterward as a blurred and powerful pattern.”

– Annie Dillard, The Writing Life, p. 32.

I have witnessed first-hand the havok that NOT having a To-Do List, a list of the items I need to work on and the things I have to do, wreaks on my life. Last year, I found it very difficult to keep track of all the things I was doing. Despite still keeping the discipline of writing in my Everything Notebook and having a broad range of planning strategies, I still struggled.

I realized that having everything scheduled on my Google Calendar was still VERY important, but even more so, maintaining a reasonably short, doable To-Do List was key to maintaining my sanity. The calendar gives me a visual overview of what I am supposed to be doing and when I’m supposed to be doing it. The To-Do List I always write it in my Everything Notebook, but also I make a point of ensuring that I have a digital version in case I don’t have my Everything Notebook with me.

Different people plan and maintain a work schedule in contrasting ways. I’ve tried several approaches, including a weekly To-Do List that is visually displayed, preferably on a whiteboard. This method used to be my preferred one, even if it required triple synchronization (Everything Notebook -> Google Calendar -> Office whiteboard). Unfortunately, I no longer have access to a whiteboard, neither at my office at FLACSO Mexico nor at home, so I’ve had to set aside this method for now.

Synchronizing weekly plans

A weekly To-Do List dashboard on a whiteboard in my former office.

Those of you who have followed me on Twitter/X for a long while or who have read my blog extensively over the years probably know my Everything Notebook-based planning technique. The goal of an Everything Notebook, as I’ve written elsewhere here on my blog, is to keep EVERYTHING in ONE single notebook, rather than having notes here and there and everywhere. It does work wonders for someone like me, who needs to have everything available and at the ready in one single place.

Filling up my To Do list a little bit AFTER the fact

A portion of my Weekly To-Do List in one of my Everything Notebooks.

“One of the secrets of getting more done is to make a TO-DO List every day, keep it visible, and use it as a guide to action as you go through the day.”
— Jean de La Fontaine

I always reserve one tab of the Everything Notebook for my Weekly To-Do List.

There are a few lessons that I’ve learned over the course of the years regarding planning, scheduling and developint To-Do Lists. I am listing a few of these here even though I’ve written about them elsewhere on my blog for your easy access and perusal.

1. A To-Do List app (or similar analog system) will not work unless you add ALL your activities to it.

You are a full person (and so am I). This means that the things we have to do for our personal life ALSO take time and need to be considered and accounted for. I used to only schedule my work items in my To-Do List. Big mistake. I can’t plan properly for the future if there are other activities that take up my time, that are absolutely vital and essential for my own survival, and that I am not listing in my To-Do List. And yes, even self-care and rest need to be put in your To-Do List. As weird as this sounds, but making time for myself has been an absolute life saver.

Coordinating calendars

I always include my personal life items in my To-Do List. This includes dentist appointments, doctors’ appointments, and care work. It’s always easy to think that you’ve done nothing when you only get two work-related items in a day because the rest of your day has been taken up by personal life maintenance items. But those are work, too! They are just not paid.

2. Synchronize your To-Do Lists across devices and analog/digital platforms

This is something that a lot of people ask me about when discussing my Everything Notebook strategy. Paper notebooks can feel cumbersome to carry around, and we may forget them at home. So, I always synchronize my To-Do List, including writing commitments, meetings, and other responsibilities.

Synchronizing To-Do lists

3. Make your To-Do Lists realistic.

I’ve written about this like a bazillion time here on my blog, but it is really true. I am the king of extra-long To-Do Lists. I want to get EVERYTHING done. And yes, I am single, no kids, able-bodied, with a permanent, tenured job (I’m a Full Professor), so I get that I have a lot of privilege. BUT I also have a natural tendency to overbook myself and think that I can do a lot more than I physically am able to, within the limits of my body.

Post-It To Do and Weekly Plans

Whether you use my Granular Planning and the Rule of Threes strategy, or the Accomplish Two Things #2ThingsADay, or your own set of rules, I can certify that it is better to have a manageable To-Do List than an endless array of items that you’ll never get crossed off your list.

4. Actually get through your To-Do List (a Done List is AMAZING):

This sounds a bit weird, I know, but seriously, if you want your To-Do List to work, you actually need to do the things. Every few weeks, I post on all my social media platforms a meme with Peter Parker explaining that to avoid stressing about the things we have in our To Do List, we need to do the things.

Peter Parker do the things

“I’ve always made lists of things I want to achieve — it helps me track my progress. But to-do lists are only useful if you do the things on your list.”
— Richard Branson

So yes, as weird as this tip sounds, you’ll feel better about your To-Do List if you actually DO the things. I have always told my students to keep a Done List (the list of what you’ve accomplished, a tip I learned from Dr. Katherine Firth), and a list of Quick Wins. Quick Wins are things you can cross off your To-Do List quickly, that require little effort, and that will help you in the end feel more accomplished.

And at the end of the month, I write a list of everything I accomplished that month.

EVERYTHING.

5. Break down the work in smaller pieces and work on ONE thing at a time, just for 30 minutes at a time:

This is a combination of 3 techniques that I’ve used over the course of my career, from grade school to full professorship: I break down every project in smaller, manageable, workable pieces, and I focus on getting ONE thing done. Even if I can’t finish the entirety of the project or the specific task I am working on, I devote at least 30 minutes to working on that task. And at the end of the month, I write a list of accomplishments and things I got done, and yes that includes every personal item, too.

As I’ve grown older and advanced in my career, I’ve come to realize that most of the challenges we face as academics when it comes to workload is that a vast majority of our time is unstructured and we need to manage multiple projects and deal with a broad range of commitments inside and outside of our institutions. And this is only those of us lucky enough to have a full time job or a well-funded scholarship to do a graduate degree. Precarity in all its forms impacts our careers and our lives in ways that are not always manageable or imaginable. But I hope these strategies that have worked for me may be useful to you all.

Posted in academia.


Paying yourself first by time-blocking your writing, thinking and researching time

“The key is to not to prioritize what’s on your schedule, but to schedule your priorities.”
― Stephen R. Covey

I can’t recall who I heard it from before, but I clearly remember someone (a senior professor, most likely) recommending that I should “pay myself first” by prioritizing my own writing over anything else I have on the docket. This was particularly important as I got my first tenure-track job. While being able to prioritize tasks is important across all career stages, for early-career-scholars it’s even more important, I think. I’ve written quite often on my blog about Organization and Time Management and also on task prioritization (blog posts associated with the latter can be found on my Planning Strategies page).

I first learned about the whole notion of scheduling writing blocks from Dr. Tanya Golash Boza, whose blog was an inspiration for mine. When I was early in my academic career, I really tried to develop a weekly template that would enable me to schedule my life to the very minute. This didn’t work well after a few years, to be perfectly honest.

Time Blocks

I have written previously about the importance of building flexibility in your calendar and making sure that you schedule enough time to get your tasks done, but I think it’s just as important to learn how to prioritize, and to be perfectly honest, I understand that prioritizing tasks is a juggling game between what others expect from us and what we need to get done in order to further our careers.

Don’t get me wrong: I am the first one to suggest that service work is very important, even for junior scholars and graduate students. Academia is, for better or worse, a guild founded on the notion of reciprocity, cooperation and collaboration. I review this manuscript for your journal or your press in hopes that other people will review my own manuscripts when I submit them. So this delicate balancing act between being generous and reciprocal and prioritizing yourself and your own work is hard.

Coordinating schedules

A screenshot of my weekly schedule showing dedicated time blocks for reading, learning and writing, and time blocks dedicated to my courses (my teaching commitments)

As you can see above, I pay myself first by scheduling my writing time BEFORE my teaching. That way, once I enter the classroom, I’ve already spent my writing time focused on my own priorities (my writing commitments, particularly).

I have suggested one strategy to deal with this: the TOTOs vs. TOMs prioritization strategy. TOTOS are Texts the I Owe To Others. TOMs are Texts that I Owe Myself. In this particular post I suggest that as much as possible, and with no detriment to others, you prioritize your TOMs first and work on those at the top of your energy levels and THEN focus on your TOTOs.

This TOTOs vs. TOMs delicate balancing act can be performed every day. For example, I prioritize my own writing every morning. The first two hours of the day are for MY own manuscripts (my TOMs). Work on drafting papers I need to finish writing and submitting, reading material that will forward my own work. Later during the day I do work on the texts that I owe others (TOTOs).

My suggestion is therefore that when you plan your weekly schedule, budget your time, and develop your To-Do List, consider the TOMs vs. TOTOs strategy and pay yourself first by blocking time to focus on your own work. This doesn’t mean that you won’t get to the things you are supposed to be doing for others, but that you put yourself at the top of the priorities list.

Posted in academia.


Developing a READING practice: 4 reasons and 5 tips

“You should write because you love the shape of stories and sentences and the creation of different words on a page. Writing comes from reading, and reading is the finest teacher of how to write.”
― Annie Proulx

In my courses, on my blog, across all my social media platforms, and everywhere I go, I always insist on the importance of developing a writing practice. Well, as I have also systematically repeated on this blog, in order to write, and particularly write well, you also need to read, therefore it is crucially important that you also develop a READING practice.

Writing at the h

In this post I offer four suggestions for you to consider how to reframe the way you see reading as an activity in order to help you develop a reading practice.

1. Reading to generate new ideas:

Reading an article or a paper or a book chapter, or a section of a book can be helpful for you to get your thinking juices flowing. I first got this suggestion from Dr. Theresa (Terre) Satterfield. When I started my PhD I asked Terre for advice on how to become a better graduate student. She described to me her daily practice: she would get to her office, get herself a coffee and start reading an article, a book chapter, or a section of a book, in order to get her creative and thinking juices flowing.

To be perfectly honest, if I give a self-reflective look at how I do things, I pretty much always read before I write. I use reading as a generative activity because it helps me get fresher ideas, or link my own thoughts to those posited by other writers. I always feel like I am carrying a huge weight whenever I face The Dreaded Blank Page. Even writing this blog post out of the blue felt like a huge challenge not having read anything and wanting to crank it out just like that.

Reading highlighting scribbling annotating

So what I did to prepare myself to write this blog post was to search on Google Scholar whether any texts on how to develop a reading practice that might have appeared interesting existed. While my search yielded no good results, what I did was to search my own blog for posts on reading. I re-read those in order to give myself new ideas for this post (I also reflected about what I wanted this post to say while showering, if I’m being honest).

Thinking of reading as a generative activity for new ideas gives you a new perspective on things and helps you get started with your writing session. Reading before writing also enables you to avoid seeing the act of reading as a waste of your time or as something you simply do not have the time to do because you have a gazillion other things to do.

2. Reading to remain self-actualized and up-to-date with the literature

A good friend told me recently that it is hard to remain up-to-date with the vast swaths of academic literature that we need to read, for our students, for our own research, for the service work we do like reviewing manuscripts or books or providing feedback to colleagues, postdoctoral researchers and or own students. While he is completely right that there’s too much to read, looking at the activity itself as a way to remain up-to-date can also prove motivating.

Batch Reading, Highlighting, Annotating, Scribbling

Here on my blog I’ve written a metric tonne of blog posts on reading that you may want to check out. Particularly important, I think, is this one on the issue that we face when discussing reading-as-writing: we end up having to legitimise reading as part and parcel of academic writing.

So we can look at the importance of a reading practice through the lenses of self-actualization: we need to systematically involve reading into our writing because that’s how we are going to be able to help our students and colleagues: by remaining up-to-date with the literature. Batch-processing is one strategy we might want to use to catch up with the literature, and in this post I offer a few other strategies that might be of use to those who want to develop a reading practice.

3. Reading as a strategy to overcome Writer’s Block

Every time a colleague of mine emails me and says “I have not been able to write, I am just blocked, help me!” I tell them to stop fighting the urge to write against their current situation and just read. Yes, this may sound counter-intuitive, but if you are facing Writer’s Block and you keep pushing yourself trying to get words out of your brain and fingers, it’s likely that nothing is going to come out and you’ll be all the more frustrated.

Book reading

Using reading as a tool to help you overcome Writer’s Block enables you to put your mind at ease and do something else. Stop focusing on generating new text and on producing words to put them on paper and start thinking of how what you are reading can nourish your brain and help you focus on what you want to learn. Because writing is a way of learning.

4. Reading as a vehicle to engage in a conversation:

This is perhaps the one that I have tried the hardest to imbue into my students: what you are writing is (or should be) in conversation with the broader literature. Who do you want to be conversing with? Which literatures, which authors, which disciplines?

Reading and taking notes in index cards

I always tell my students that in order for them to make a contribution to the literature, they need to map out and discern WHERE they are making a contribution. They can only do that by reading what is out there.

Book reading

Ok, I have justified why you need to develop a reading practice. So now, how do you go about it? I’m going to share 5 tips that summarize what I’ve learned over the many years I’ve written this blog, taught courses on academic writing and research, and mentored and supervised thesis students. Hopefully some of these strategies will be of help to you.

5 tips to start developing your reading practice:

1. Clarify for yourself WHY you are reading.

Are you reading to catch up with the literature? To better understand a topic? To help a graduate student with their thesis? To learn a new method? Because you are writing a grant proposal and need to engage with and learn about an entirely new topic from scratch? All of these are genuinely valid reasons why you need to read. Just make it clear for yourself.

Side note: I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had to read dozens of books and journal articles and book articles just to understand what my graduate students are working on. I supervise students on a very broad range of topics, so I need to delve into entirely new literatures ALL THE TIME.

2. Book time to read, even if it’s just 15-30 minutes.

I completely understand why you might scoff at this one. “Who has time to read (for pleasure/for work) when I have to send 433 emails, prepare 6 classes, deal with stuff at home, etc.”. Absolutely legitimate concerns. Reading (and writing) often get relegated to the very bottom of the To-Do List. But making SOME time to read can be useful as you develop your reading practice. It doesn’t have to be a 2 day reading retreat (though that kind of sounds lovely). It can be just 15 minutes a day. But making reading a systematic, consistent habit can be helpful as you work to develop a reading practice.

3. Read like a writer.

Yes, this one seems also quite obvious but it is true. And the best book to learn how to read as a writer is Francine Prose’s Reading Like a Writer. It’s an amazing book that teaches you how to read with a view to improve your written prose. Read with the intention to learn how other writers craft their sentences, their paragraphs, their pages, their arguments.

4. Prioritize what you need to read.

I tend to look at everything I have to do and sometimes feel overwhelmed because I don’t know what to focus on. But that’s when I look at my To-Do List and my writing commitments, and I prioritize what I need to read according to those. For example, I am finishing a chapter on qualitative methods. I really want to read a lot of stuff on organizational ethnography, a topic where I have published relatively little. But for now, I need to prioritize my reading and focus on the topic of qualitative methods for political science, public policy and public administration. I’ll make time to read other stuff as soon as I am done with this chapter.

5. Do “Active Reading” (take notes as you read)

This one is quite important. I love reading a book as I go, but the truth is, if I want to use what I am reading as fodder for my writing, I need to take notes. I have written blog posts about how to take notes from books when you can’t write on them (I do not write on any books), and other techniques for note-taking, but more generally, I always recommend to my students that they read and take notes as they progress with their reading. You can also use voice notes if that works better for you.

Hopefully this blog post will re-ignite the reading practice you once had, or help you build one if it’s something you’ve always struggled with. OR maybe this post will inspire you to start reading again if you’ve fallen behind.

Posted in academia.


6 tips to re-start your writing practice

It’s happened to all of us who write: multiple conflicting commitments, “everything is due yesterday”, we need to deal with life on an every day basis. The end result: we stop writing. And that’s a HUGE challenge for those of us who make a living out of our writing, be it that we are academics, faculty, early career scholars, postdoctoral researchers, professors, or writers, more broadly.

Writing

Over the past few weeks, a number of scholars I admire and whose writing I love have come to me for advice on how to regain confidence in their writing, how to switch types and modes of writing, and more broadly, how to re-start their writing practice. This phenomenon (where I stop writing for myriad reasons).

First of all, I’d like to make two points about the challenge that restarting and sustaining a writing practice poses very, very clear:

  1. It happens to ALL OF US.
  2. You can snap out of it and re-start your writing practice.

It’s easy to leave writing to the bottom of our To-Do List. After all, there are always pressing matters to attend to. In addition to our personal lives, which are and should be the priority (we are humans, after all), we have meetings with students, colleagues, coauthors, teaching duties that include preparing materials, reading, grading, mentoring, service to our discipline, our field, and our institutions.

Thus, writing seems like something that can be left to “whenever I have a few hours clear in my schedule”. This approach detracts from enabling us to attend to a key component of our scholarly lives.

Highlighting, scribbling marginalia, reading, writing

Here are a few tips that may help you re-start your writing practice. I write these out of experience: these are the things I’ve done when I’ve fallen behind in my writing and when I need to get things out (or more importantly, when I realize that writing is an integral component of my life as a scholar, and that I need to get back into it.

  1. Block a reasonable period of time in your calendar where you can focus on writing.
  2. Set a reasonable goal for your writing objectives, then slowly increase.
  3. Re-start your reading practice, and use these reading materials as “brain fodder” for your writing.
  4. Stop beating yourself up if you fail to write one day, and just write the following day.
  5. Build repetition and routine into your schedule.
  6. Ask for help and rely on your community (including writing groups and coaches).

1. Block a reasonable period of time in your calendar where you can focus on writing.

In my calendar, I have scheduled time to write Monday through Friday. My goal is to spend 2 hours in writing-related activities, which may include reading (yes, reading IS writing), data analysis, outlining, etc.

Calendar Screenshot

I realize that not everybody can block 2 hours of their daily lives to write, and that not everybody can wake up at 4:00 in the morning (which is my normal wake-up time). I think that’s ok. We all write when we can. But blocking SOME time can help you focus. Book a meeting with yourself, a Meeting With Your Writing (as my dear friend Jo Van Every has defined it).

Claim that time as your own and use it to write. Even if it is only 15 minutes.

2. Set a reasonable goal for your writing objectives, then slowly increase.

I am the first one to establish unreasonable goals and targets for myself. Unfortunately, this comes from always pushing myself and thinking that I can do A LOT MORE than I can reasonably do within the limits of my physique. I am not as young as I used to be, and I can’t work long hours. When I was in graduate school, during my PhD, I clearly recall I worked A LOT of hours, and really intensely. I can no longer do this. So I have worked really hard at setting reasonable goals, for everything, including my writing.

The Social Hub (Delft, The Netherlands)

What is a reasonable goal for your own writing practice? I can’t answer that question, only YOU can decide what is reasonable. My dear friend Leanne Powner says that our brains can only reasonably work deeply focused for about 3-4 hours a day. I think this figure changes a lot depending on who you talk to, and whose research you read, but what’s clear is that we can’t focus for 8 hours a day. So, if you are in the process of re-starting your writing practice, perhaps choose a reasonable goal: 50-75 words? 10-15 minutes? Anything. Whatever amount of time/number of words will make you feel satisfied after you are done.

3. Re-start your reading practice, and use these reading materials as “brain fodder” for your writing.

It’s funny that every time ANYBODY asks me for writing advice, I go back to my own blog and read pieces I’ve already written. And that’s part of the writing process: reading IS an integral component of writing. But just like we tend to leave our writing to the last minute, when we are already buried under a pile of commitments and have to desperately search for pockets of time here and there to complete overdue writing assignments, we also tend to leave reading to the last minute, when we REALLY need to get up to speed on a topic because we need to finish a paper that is way overdue. I am guilty of this as anyone, so what I do is I get back to my reading practice (and I do have a forthcoming blog post on how to develop a reading practice that I plan to write as soon as I am out of the woods with a few overdue scholarly writing commitments!)

Writing a draft of a paper by taking notes and writing memos

What I do when I am working to re-start my writing practice is that I set a goal of reading BEFORE I write. I learned this strategy in graduate school and I use it to this day that I am a Full Professor. It’s part of my pre-writing routine. Integrating reading with my writing routine enables me to get my thinking juices flowing.

If you can’t read an article or a book chapter a day, which I strongly recommend as a general guideline, then perhaps you may need to book some time (again, a meeting with yourself and only yourself) and batch-process some articles, book chapters and/or books. Batch-processing can help you catch up with the literature within a reasonably short period of time.

4. Stop beating yourself up if you fail to write one day, and just write the following day.

I am guilty of this as well. If I skip writing ANY day, I feel terrible, and then I bury my head in the sand. Don’t do this. We all feel overwhelmed, and current global circumstances don’t help either. So if you skipped ONE day of writing, then just write the next day. One day will not make a difference, but a series of days will create inertia and make the goal of re-starting your writing practice an unsurmountable challenge.

The real challenge lies not in the missed day itself, but in the mindset that we often fall into. When we allow ourselves to feel guilty, we frequently avoid the page the next day (The Dreaded Blank Page syndrome), and then the next, until returning feels almost impossible.

My full process for writing a paper

This inertia builds, not because we missed one day, but because we let self-judgment paralyze us. To counter this, I suggest that you make a conscious choice to return to your writing as soon as possible, even if it’s just for ten minutes. So, in my view, returning to the page after a missed day is the real win. It’s not about perfection, it’s about building momentum and cultivating a resilient, sustainable writing practice. What matters is not never failing, but developing the habit of returning, again and again, to our writing, and being kind to ourselves, always.

5. Build repetition and routine into your schedule.

Writing one day and then stopping for a month will not help you develop a sustainable writing practice.

I am a Virgo, Type A, Upholder. I need structure in my life. But even if you are not a person who loves structure, routine can still give you tools to restart your writing practice. If you make writing part of your routine, chances are that you will start getting into the flow. One of the main challenges I found as a graduate student, particularly during my PhD, was that I had all this unstructured time and I was supposed to produce a master piece of independent research

Mi oficina en la FLACSO México

Developing a structured routine for reading and writing was one of the keys to my successful completion of the doctorate. Even though as I’ve mentioned, I’m a Virgo, Type A, Upholder, I am also someone with many interests. It’s sometimes hard for me to focus. My symbol is the hummingbird for good reason. I jump from topic to topic the same way a hummingbird flies from flower to flower. And like hummingbirds, I also get tired easily. So creating a routine and a structure for my academia-related activities, particularly my writing, is fundamental for me, and perhaps it will help you, too.

6. Ask for help and rely on your community (including writing groups and coaches).

This is perhaps the most challenging of all the tips I have to share, because asking for help is hard. I struggle with this all the time. I am usually the one who helps others, I am not usually the one who requests help. But as with anything else in academia, and life more generally, asking for help is part and parcel of our life in society. Whenever I’ve been really overwhelmed and unable to produce words, I usually ask good friends for either advice or support writing in collective.

Desk in my room (Malakoff, France)

Writing groups are an amazing tool to help us develop a writing practice. I began participating in (and hosting) writing groups early during the first few months of the C0VID19 pandemic. Personally, I find that being part of a writing group really does encourage me to continue writing, even when I don’t feel like it, because I am surrounded by other like-minded folks who are working hard to get their writing commitments completed.

Perhaps you may also want to hire a writing coach or attend a writing workshop. I teach several of these workshops every year, across the globe, and for different audiences, from PhD students to full professors. This strategy of hiring a writing coach or attending a writing workshop really depends on your budget. I don’t want anybody to break the bank to hire help. But the reality is that these workshops and coaches might prove useful to you.

4 additional tips about how to develop a writing practice can be found in this blog post.

Hopefully these 6 tips will be useful to you as you work to re-start your writing practice.

Posted in academia, writing.

Tagged with , , .


Learning how to deal with rejection in academia…

REAL TALK: I’m a full professor (have been for a few years now) and I have had …

1) journal articles desk rejected.
2) articles rejected AFTER at least one if not TWO ROUNDS of Revise-And-Resubmit
3) articles published after FIVE rounds of R&R
4) a reviewer tell me that my writing sucks “as an undergrad’s”

Writing a paper

I don’t know if this helps junior and up-and-coming scholars (and students), but the reality is that these shitty things happen to us, on a regular basis.

Dr. Mirya Holman keeps a tally of how many rejections she gets (because it means she is getting her work out, peer-reviewed).

Dr. Sara Mitchel keeps a “shadow” CV with rejections.

It’s normal to have our work rejected. It sucks, and I (like any other human being) also sulk, get angry, dwell on it.

I’ve had manuscripts that have laid dormant for YEARS because I couldn’t tackle the necessary revisions for the R&R to get published (see my recent post on zombie papers and book manuscripts).

I hope to motivate anybody who ALSO feels like I do. I hate having my work rejected (and criticized in a way that I feel is unfair, too), but it’s part and parcel of the academic enterprise. So we need to learn how to cope with it (sorry if you came to this post hoping to find strategies to better endure and survive rejection, I don’t think I have special advice other than dust yourself off, get up and keep moving forward).

And when it’s your turn to review, be as kind as you’d like others to be with your work.

Posted in academia, writing.

Tagged with , , .


Developing a sustainable writing practice

One of the first things I teach my students *and* my thesis advisees is how to develop a writing practice.

15 minutes of writing

Perhaps the most challenging thing in the Hidden Curriculum of being a graduate students, one of the many things *I* wasn’t taught, was the idea of a writing practice, the “how to” of crafting paragraphs and creating papers and book chapters, and dissertation components. Nobody taught me how to do this. What is the process by which graduate students can learn to systematically put words down and produce texts?

Having a writing practice doesn’t mean that you write every day. Yes, for the better part of two decades, I’ve been a proponent and fan (not a tyrant, though!) of writing every single day of the work week.

But guess what? I’ve also gotten sick. I’ve travelled. My parents have required care. All of the above has made it extremely challenging for me to sustain 2 hours of daily researching, reading, thinking and writing, as I normally would do.

As I’ve written before, a sustainable writing practice is one where the process of producing words and putting them on the page/screen is part of a workflow. Something that can be done with less friction than we normally face on an everyday basis.

Perhaps your writing happens once a week/biweekly.

a sustainable writing practice

I’ve written about all three elements of my proposed sustainable writing practice, and you can find those posts on my blog. But here they are for your perusal.

1. A system that works for you.

I’m an early morning riser. My ex-boyfriend was a super-early-morning person. I had to change my habits. Once I realized he wasn’t going to become a night owl, I slowly switched to a morning schedule that would give me 2 hours of writing alone and the remainder of the morning (until we both left for work) available to spend with him. So I moved to a 4:00am wake up time. Writing very early in the morning (4-6 am normally, when my body allows, 7-8 am when I’m tired or I’ve been travelling) is what makes my life easier.

I am NOT advocating for YOU to go to that schedule. I am saying that you need to find what works best FOR YOU. Which time slot you can use to put some words down, to read materials that you need to absorb in order to write.

2. A structure of work that is feasible.

I would pay good money to be able to just send my thoughts telepathically to the page. This device hasn’t happened yet, so I have learned to adapt.

For me, the time I block to write is TO WRITE. I do research, think, outline, draft, create topic sentences. Like pretty much every single faculty member I know, I have to read dissertation and theses’ drafts, prepare lectures, write papers, travel to conferences, do care work, etc.

The reason why I write so early in the morning is also that it makes it feasible for me to THINK and LEARN and WRITE. Every single time I’ve broken up with a guy, it has been late at night, when we are both tired, and not thinking very clearly. I am a morning person. A VERY EARLY MORNING person. I think well up until about 2pm. Anything I do after noon-2pm should be stuff that doesn’t require me to think clearly.

I protect my writing time fiercely. You’ll see me pushing for meetings AFTER 11 in the morning. For some reason, people seem to really like to take meetings in the morning. That’s MY writing time. So I compromise. I don’t say “no meetings before 4pm”, I just say “any time after 11am is good for me”.

I also prefer to teach in the afternoons. But this isn’t always possible. So I delay teaching as late as possible within the reasonable limits of what my university requires (usually my classes start at 11 am or 4pm, but I’ve also been known to teach at 8am).

Teaching in the afternoon is easier for me.

But more importantly, I think the most important element of a sustainable writing practice is item # 3:

3. A piece of writing output that is doable.

So, turns out that I am not able to write for as long as I would like to (2 hours per day, 5 days a week). Well, I’ll write whatever I can take. And I won’t stress about it: I’ll do it MEMO BY MEMO. I borrowed the Memo-Writing practice from qualitative methods (I only learned what qualitative research methods entailed until I did my PhD – thank you UBC School of Nursing and UBC School of Social Work – I am a political scientist and a human geographer who first learned how to conduct qualitative inquiry from nurses and social workers).

#AcWri on a plane

Now that you know what I consider the elements of a sustainable writing practice, here are (in my view) the 3 key habits that you need to implement on a regular basis in order to DEVELOP A SUSTAINABLE WRITING PRACTICE:

1. Start small.
2. Break down the work in manageable pieces.
3. Make of writing part of your daily routine and integrate it into your workflow.

I will explain what I mean by each one of these habits:

1. START SMALL:

I don’t set out to finish a chapter, an article, not even a section.

I set out to write a certain number of words or a specific amount of time. When I teach learners this method, I encourage them to focus on 125 words, 15 minutes. Focusing on a small target or goal makes it much easier to create a habit of producing a specific number of words over a certain period of time.

2. BREAK DOWN THE WORK IN MANAGEABLE PIECES

Do I need to finish revisions to a chapter this week? Yes.

Can I do them in one day? Unlikely.

BUT I can focus on writing a memo that addresses 1-2 comments from the editors, breaking these into smaller pieces. Being able to systematically decompose an entire task or work package into smaller pieces makes it easier to focus JUST on one of those tasks. Remaining focused on a small piece of work also makes slow-but-steady progress feasible.

3. INTEGRATE WRITING INTO YOUR DAILY ROUTINE/WORKFLOW

I am a Virgo, Type A, Upholder. I have my Moon in Virgo, my Venus in Virgo, and my ascent in Virgo. I’m the Virgo-est Virgo to have ever Virgo-ed. Organization and structure are the backbone of my life.

Do I face challenges in my daily life and do I need to deal with what comes my way in unexpected ways? Heck, of course I do. But disorganization really screws up my life. I need structure. Even within the whirlwind that my life is, I have to keep things organized and under control.

AcWri while travelling

With my graduate students (I no longer supervise undergrads) I always try to show them the benefits of a structured daily routine. I developed my writing, reading and research habits well before I got to graduate school. But it was during the PhD that I found lack of structure most challenging.

When I started my PhD, I quickly realized that grad school is VERY unstructured. For someone like me, lack of structure is extremely disorienting. So I forced myself to retain structure: I took graduate school as a job, I worked at my desk on campus, etc.

My hope is that this blog post and those linked throughout will be useful to those of you who are seeking to develop a sustainable writing practice.

Posted in academia.

Tagged with , .


Of zombie papers and manuscripts…

I have A LOT of zombie papers and book manuscripts…

Highlighting, scribbling marginalia, reading, writing

You all know those zombie papers and manuscripts: things you wrote, you ALMOST completed, you sent out for peer review and got a revise-and-resubmit that you never converted into published articles, books that were nearly completely written or edited, that perhaps got lost in the peer review because you could not fathom complete the revisions.

Those are zombie papers and manuscripts.

These manuscripts and papers haven’t died a slow death yet, but somehow remain in the imagination of researchers. I asked on BlueSky how do people deal with zombie papers and manuscripts.

A summary of responses here:

  • Some people use bits and pieces of the zombie papers to revamp and refine ideas.
  • Others were happy to just leave them be and make peace with the fact that these projects will never come to fruition.
  • And others said they do come back to their old projects.

Writing on campus

What I found extremely useful were the prompting questions about why I am hanging on to zombie projects:

  • Dr. Nicole Janz asked “are they sunk cost projects that you really should leave behind, or low hanging fruits that deserve one last polish? Do they push you towards your Future Self and help you set your next 5 years’ agenda?”
  • Dr. Nico Trajtenberg asked: “Are they still an intellectual challenge or you just dislike sunk costs?”

Personally, I do not like sunk cost projects. I have already invested a lot of time and energy (and in some cases, research grant money) for those projects to be gone and done with. I also think some of them (or for the most part, ALL OF THEM) are low hanging fruits that I could potentially revamp quite quickly.

I have three full book manuscripts in that zombie stage: I am pretty much done with the writing, with the fieldwork, and I just need to put some effort into getting them in the shape that they can then be submitted to the press. I also have a few journal article manuscripts that I plan to “resuscitate”.

However, I already have given up on a few R&Rs. I decided that it wasn’t worth my energy and all the effort to convert them. Some of them, the reviewers required extra fieldwork or analyses.

I am totally NOT doing that.

I’d be interested to hear from my readers on what you would do with your zombie papers.

  • Do you plan to let them sit idle for a while and pick them up again?
  • Do you want to just be done with them and not return to them?
  • Will you pick up some pieces and bits and use them for newer work?

Posted in academia, writing.


A new year, a new era, and a new beginning for my blog

As most of those of you who read my blog regularly can see, I’ve been blogging less in 2022, 2023 and 2024. I am not certain that this was a product of more work at my university, but instead, a bit of a writer’s block because of fear of uselessness. Let me explain.

Writing

When I began blogging (in 2006, 18 years ago), I did so to build a space for myself to think out loud, to write to a different audience (that was not entirely academic but also not the general public). As time has gone by, thousands of people began reading my blog and using my resources, either for themselves or to teach others how to do certain things in academia. While that made me extraordinarily proud (and still is a high point for me), it also made me feel responsible for posting USEFUL stuff.

And then, at some point, my blog stopped being (for me) a space for self-reflection and think things out loud, and began to remain in my head as a resource that I had to maintain, in one way or another. I felt that I didn’t have enough topics to blog about. That also led to a drought, and huge gaps on my blog.

This end-of-the-year in 2024 helped me think that this is not really a smart way of approaching my blog, especially for me. Yes, I want to write useful stuff, and particularly things that have been revealed to me through the many years I’ve been in academia (and government, and civil society, and industry), but I also want to have a space where I just dump thoughts and think things through. I’ll still write things that I have learned that I feel that might be useful for people to read, but I will also dump here my self-reflections whenever I feel that I need to think things through.

I hope that my blog and resources pages will remain useful for readers, but I also hope that rethinking my approach to blogging will enable me to feel even more free to write about the things that I am thinking about but I don’t have a scholarly space (in a journal or a book) to write.

Here’s to a new era and a new beginning for my blog.

Posted in academia.

Tagged with .


Connecting your specific research to broader questions in the literature, the field and the discipline

I am currently mentoring a few academics (my own PhD students and a few early-career TT scholars) and I am trying to teach them about how to frame their work in terms of the broader questions of a field, and a discipline. The kind of exercise I am executing, trying to teach how to connect specific case studies and approaches to the broader literature is not easy. The “hidden curriculum” is pervasive.

The Governance of Bottled Water in Mexico

Me giving a talk to students associated with the Center for Latin American Studies at the University of California Berkeley

So, how do we frame our work in terms of discipline- or field-wide questions or contributions to broader debates in the literature?

Here are three strategies that might help you frame your work more broadly and link your specific work to the larger discipline- and field-wide questions (click on each link to take you to the specific blog post where I already wrote in more detail about each strategy):

Each of the strands of my scholarly work contributes to different debates across disciplines, and to broader questions in the literature of each discipline and field. Below you will find some examples:

Example 1: One of my research areas is transnational environmental activism. While the case studies I examine are based in North America (Canada, the US and Mexico), my works speaks to broader debates on activism, protest and social movements. My research challenges preconceived notions and conventional wisdom that environmental non-governmental organization across countries form coalitions based on their shared values. Instead, I empirically demonstrate that the basis for collaboration and cooperation is a shared strategy, and to achieve consensus on these strategies, ENGOs share knowledge across borders and across the board.

This research strand and the projects I’ve conducted within it speak to broader debates on coalition-building within sociology, but also larger questions in international relations on the role of non-state actors in domestic, transnational and global politics and policy.

Example 2. Also within the realm of transnational environmental activism, but more specifically within the shaming and blaming academic bodies of literature in human rights scholarship and international relations, my work demonstrates empirically that countries are substantially receptive to external, non-state actors’ pressures to engage in domestic policy change. Our (Amanda Murdie and mine) research shows that environmental NGOs pusing for improved conditions have more success in countries where there is receptiveness and where civil society are substantively galvanized and organized.

Example 3: Another research area of mine is the governance of bottled water, primarily as an example of a negative commons. While the phenomenon I analyze (packaging a common pool resource, a commons) is rather specific (bottled water), in my work I dialogue with broader questions of resource governance, enclosure, property rights, etc. This empirical and theoretical work contributes to global debates on the human right to water, marketization and privatization. I extend the notion of commons (common pool resources) beyond its traditional boundaries and offer the definition of a negative commons: a commons that is only valued after a revaluation process, not intrinsically. Solid waste, wastewater and bottled water are all negative commons, according to my definition.

My work on bottled water also contributes to political science and public policy literatures, particularly to those focused on the interplay between interests, ideas and institutions. I show how bottled water consumption has increased not only as a result of increased marketing, a taste for “pure” water, and poor urban infrastructure but also as the result of weak regulatory regimes.

Example 4: I also study public policy (specifically policy instruments). While much of my work is specific to environmental regulation, I contribute to broader discussions on policy mixes, policy implementation, etc. My research demonstrates that policy instruments, particularly of the regulatory nature, work best when implemented in the form of policy mixes. This research contributes to debates on policy instrument design and implementation within the policy sciences literatures.

The following published pieces from other scholars do a masterful job of connecting their specific scholarship to broader questions and debates in their fields and disciplines.

In their article, Kiley and Vasey explain how their empirical results have implications for cultural sociology and political sociology, as well as for methodological advances on measurement of, and stability of cultural change.

In this article, Humphreys and Weinstein explain how using field experiments can help us tackle broader questions in the political economy of development.

Demonstrating how specific research projects answer and are linked to broader questions and debates in the scholarly literature is challenging, but it is also an important task that we need to undertake in order to demonstrate that we have made a contribution to the literature.

Hopefully this blog post will help you in this process!

Posted in academia, research, research design, research methods.

Tagged with , .


The value and importance of the pre-writing stage of writing

A lot of people ask me about my actual writing process, so I figured I should share some of my practices, and make them into blog posts. I’m lucky that, as I write this blog post, I have a full day available to write (no meetings).

The first element of my writing practice is the pre-writing stage.

I am a person of rituals and routines.

First, I brew a pot of coffee. My first cup of coffee is very important as it’s what sets the tone for the day. I take a few minutes to just be with myself and have my coffee.

Coffee

I am a Virgo, Type A, Upholder. I need routines and organization. The next step in my daily writing practice is what many call the Pre-Writing Stage.

I am not the kind of person who does “stream of consciousness” writing. I need to read first to get my thinking juices flowing. A number of people who write about writing recommend doing “Morning Pages”. This is a method developed by writer Julia Cameron. Three pages, stream-of-consciousness. This method is very helpful if you are feeling VERY stuck. I will be very honest and say that I don’t use it often.

Personally, I write by memorandums and using outlines. What does this mean, in practice? Well, I don’t write entire papers. I don’t even write entire sections.

I write memos.

Memo v 4 second paragraph filled

The key, however, is to write EFFECTIVE memos. Memos that you’ll use. Memos that you can copy-and-paste into your papers.

In this particular blog post, however, I want to emphasize the Pre-Writing Stage, because I find that not having a routine that helps me focus completely hinders my ability to generate words. My Pre-Writing Stage includes drinking a cup of coffee, centering myself, but also READING.

I need to read in order to get my brain in order to write. I can’t just blurt words out.

What does my Pre-Writing Routine entail?

Pre-Writing in my case ALWAYS implies at least 4 things:

  1. Look over at my list of writing commitments (and prioritize what I need to write first. Deadlines are great for this!)
  2. Check which memos I’ve written and which ones need to be written.
  3. Read about the topic.
  4. Review which particular memo I need to write based on the paper outline I’ve generated.

For example, right now I’m writing about how research questions fit with other components of the research design process. So I re-read a few materials I’ve read about this specific topic, from articles to books.

Pre-writing stage

I find that sometimes, people think that reading is NOT part of their writing practice, and that the time they spend reading BEFORE starting to write is somehow a waste of time.

For me, reading and often times, re-reading is what gives me the brain fuel to start writing. READING IS WRITING. There’s no way around it. If you want to write, you need to read.

Though sometimes I can, in fact, sit down and start producing words, I find that doing a bit of re-reading and THEN sketching on paper what I’m going to write about and how I’m going to do it helps me. I usually sketch and draft on index cards, this helps me think through ideas.

Pre-writing stage

As you can see from the photo above, I developed 4 Guiding Questions that will help me start writing. I classify Guiding Questions as part of the “Prompts” category.

Writing Prompts, as their name suggest, are elements that help you get started, that set actions in motion.

Because I am writing about Research Questions, the 4 Guiding Questions that will act as prompts for me are:

  • what is a research question?
  • what elements or characteristics would make a research question “good”?
  • what are the different types and typologies of RQs?
  • how are research questions linked to other elements of research design?

I usually generate ONE memorandum per prompt. This breakdown of the work allows me to feel less overwhelmed.

I don’t think to hit 2,000 words. I just need to answer ONE Guiding Question.

To summarize my Pre-Writing Routine:

  1. Writing, most often than not, may require a Pre-Writing Routine. Mine includes reading, planning, organizing my thoughts and drinking coffee.
  2. A Pre-Writing Routine that includes reading and sketching your thoughts may be helpful to you as you develop your writing practice. Make the best of outlines.
  3. You don’t have to write 5,000 words per day. All you need to worry about is just a few words, a few minutes. ONE Memorandum.

I hope this blog post is useful to you as you develop your writing practice.

Carrie Bradshaw Pre Writing Routine

Posted in academia, writing.

Tagged with , , , .